init: Stop combining actions
In the past, I had thought it didn't make sense to have multiple
Action classes with identical triggers within ActionManager::actions_,
and opted to instead combine these into a single action. In theory,
it should reduce memory overhead as only one copy of the triggers
needs to be stored.
In practice, this ends up not being a good idea.
Most importantly, given a file with the below three sections in this
same order:
on boot
setprop a b
on boot && property:true=true
setprop c d
on boot
setprop e f
Assuming that property 'true' == 'true', when the `boot` event
happens, the order of the setprop commands will actually be:
setprop a b
setprop e f
setprop c d
instead of the more intuitive order of:
setprop a b
setprop c d
setprop e f
This is a mistake and this CL fixes it. It also documents this order.
Secondly, with a given 'Action' now spanning multiple files, in order
to keep track of which file a command is run from, the 'Command'
itself needs to store this. Ironically to the original intention,
this increases total ram usage. This change now only stores the file
name in each 'Action' instead of each 'Command'. All in all this is a
negligible trade off of ram usage.
Thirdly, this requires a bunch of extra code and assumptions that
don't help anything else. In particular it forces to keep property triggers
sorted for easy comparison, which I'm using an std::map for currently,
but that is not the best data structure to contain them.
Lastly, I added the filename and line number to the 'processing
action' LOG(INFO) message.
Test: Boot bullhead, observe above changes
Test: Boot sailfish, observe no change in boot time
Change-Id: I3fbcac4ee677351314e33012c758145be82346e9
diff --git a/init/action.cpp b/init/action.cpp
index 347edb0..c128968 100644
--- a/init/action.cpp
+++ b/init/action.cpp
@@ -26,10 +26,8 @@
using android::base::Join;
using android::base::StringPrintf;
-Command::Command(BuiltinFunction f, const std::vector<std::string>& args,
- const std::string& filename, int line)
- : func_(f), args_(args), filename_(filename), line_(line) {
-}
+Command::Command(BuiltinFunction f, const std::vector<std::string>& args, int line)
+ : func_(f), args_(args), line_(line) {}
int Command::InvokeFunc() const {
std::vector<std::string> expanded_args;
@@ -49,21 +47,12 @@
return Join(args_, ' ');
}
-std::string Command::BuildSourceString() const {
- if (!filename_.empty()) {
- return StringPrintf(" (%s:%d)", filename_.c_str(), line_);
- } else {
- return std::string();
- }
-}
-
-Action::Action(bool oneshot) : oneshot_(oneshot) {
-}
+Action::Action(bool oneshot, const std::string& filename, int line)
+ : oneshot_(oneshot), filename_(filename), line_(line) {}
const KeywordMap<BuiltinFunction>* Action::function_map_ = nullptr;
-bool Action::AddCommand(const std::vector<std::string>& args,
- const std::string& filename, int line, std::string* err) {
+bool Action::AddCommand(const std::vector<std::string>& args, int line, std::string* err) {
if (!function_map_) {
*err = "no function map available";
return false;
@@ -79,20 +68,12 @@
return false;
}
- AddCommand(function, args, filename, line);
+ AddCommand(function, args, line);
return true;
}
-void Action::AddCommand(BuiltinFunction f,
- const std::vector<std::string>& args,
- const std::string& filename, int line) {
- commands_.emplace_back(f, args, filename, line);
-}
-
-void Action::CombineAction(const Action& action) {
- for (const auto& c : action.commands_) {
- commands_.emplace_back(c);
- }
+void Action::AddCommand(BuiltinFunction f, const std::vector<std::string>& args, int line) {
+ commands_.emplace_back(f, args, line);
}
std::size_t Action::NumCommands() const {
@@ -122,7 +103,7 @@
android::base::GetMinimumLogSeverity() <= android::base::DEBUG) {
std::string trigger_name = BuildTriggersString();
std::string cmd_str = command.BuildCommandString();
- std::string source = command.BuildSourceString();
+ std::string source = StringPrintf(" (%s:%d)", filename_.c_str(), command.line());
LOG(INFO) << "Command '" << cmd_str << "' action=" << trigger_name << source
<< " returned " << result << " took " << duration_ms << "ms.";
@@ -234,11 +215,6 @@
return event_trigger_.empty() && CheckPropertyTriggers(name, value);
}
-bool Action::TriggersEqual(const Action& other) const {
- return property_triggers_ == other.property_triggers_ &&
- event_trigger_ == other.event_trigger_;
-}
-
std::string Action::BuildTriggersString() const {
std::vector<std::string> triggers;
@@ -306,17 +282,7 @@
}
void ActionManager::AddAction(std::unique_ptr<Action> action) {
- auto old_action_it =
- std::find_if(actions_.begin(), actions_.end(),
- [&action] (std::unique_ptr<Action>& a) {
- return action->TriggersEqual(*a);
- });
-
- if (old_action_it != actions_.end()) {
- (*old_action_it)->CombineAction(*action);
- } else {
- actions_.emplace_back(std::move(action));
- }
+ actions_.emplace_back(std::move(action));
}
void ActionManager::QueueEventTrigger(const std::string& trigger) {
@@ -332,16 +298,15 @@
QueuePropertyTrigger("", "");
}
-void ActionManager::QueueBuiltinAction(BuiltinFunction func,
- const std::string& name) {
- auto action = std::make_unique<Action>(true);
+void ActionManager::QueueBuiltinAction(BuiltinFunction func, const std::string& name) {
+ auto action = std::make_unique<Action>(true, "<Builtin Action>", 0);
std::vector<std::string> name_vector{name};
if (!action->InitSingleTrigger(name)) {
return;
}
- action->AddCommand(func, name_vector);
+ action->AddCommand(func, name_vector, 0);
trigger_queue_.push(std::make_unique<BuiltinTrigger>(action.get()));
actions_.emplace_back(std::move(action));
@@ -366,7 +331,8 @@
if (current_command_ == 0) {
std::string trigger_name = action->BuildTriggersString();
- LOG(INFO) << "processing action (" << trigger_name << ")";
+ LOG(INFO) << "processing action (" << trigger_name << ") from (" << action->filename()
+ << ":" << action->line() << ")";
}
action->ExecuteOneCommand(current_command_);
@@ -397,15 +363,15 @@
}
}
-bool ActionParser::ParseSection(const std::vector<std::string>& args,
- std::string* err) {
+bool ActionParser::ParseSection(const std::vector<std::string>& args, const std::string& filename,
+ int line, std::string* err) {
std::vector<std::string> triggers(args.begin() + 1, args.end());
if (triggers.size() < 1) {
*err = "actions must have a trigger";
return false;
}
- auto action = std::make_unique<Action>(false);
+ auto action = std::make_unique<Action>(false, filename, line);
if (!action->InitTriggers(triggers, err)) {
return false;
}
@@ -414,10 +380,9 @@
return true;
}
-bool ActionParser::ParseLineSection(const std::vector<std::string>& args,
- const std::string& filename, int line,
- std::string* err) const {
- return action_ ? action_->AddCommand(args, filename, line, err) : false;
+bool ActionParser::ParseLineSection(const std::vector<std::string>& args, int line,
+ std::string* err) {
+ return action_ ? action_->AddCommand(args, line, err) : false;
}
void ActionParser::EndSection() {