commit 9c922979d28d8e0d58d2537c9551b1346b0a27a1
author Tomasz Wasilczyk <twasilczyk@google.com> Wed Jan 05 13:05:41 2022 -0800
committer Tomasz Wasilczyk <twasilczyk@google.com> Thu Jan 06 03:25:37 2022 +0000
tree a1bff90a5dfd5243bfa6d346024c02227b5baf51
parent fab263ceaee2a1aab58c7d0841921d61c06766ec

Fix minor TODOs in HIDL-AIDL translation shim

Bug: 203699028
Bug: 210498497
Test: build and boot Cuttlefish
Change-Id: I82dd52f313b5768cfccf0d6a7705b28dfcff24fa

radio/aidl/compat/libradiocompat/RadioResponse.cpp

diff --git a/radio/aidl/compat/libradiocompat/RadioResponse.cpp b/radio/aidl/compat/libradiocompat/RadioResponse.cpp
index dbeb68a..dab70cc 100644
--- a/radio/aidl/compat/libradiocompat/RadioResponse.cpp
+++ b/radio/aidl/compat/libradiocompat/RadioResponse.cpp
@@ -26,7 +26,10 @@
 
 Return<void> RadioResponse::acknowledgeRequest(int32_t serial) {
     LOG_CALL << serial;
-    // TODO(b/203699028): send to correct requestor or confirm if spam is not a problem
+    /* We send ACKs to all callbacks instead of the one requested it to make implementation simpler.
+     * If it turns out to be a problem, we would have to track where serials come from and make sure
+     * this tracking data (e.g. a map) doesn't grow indefinitely.
+     */
     if (mDataCb) mDataCb.get()->acknowledgeRequest(serial);
     if (mMessagingCb) mMessagingCb.get()->acknowledgeRequest(serial);
     if (mModemCb) mModemCb.get()->acknowledgeRequest(serial);

radio/aidl/compat/libradiocompat/network/RadioNetwork.cpp

diff --git a/radio/aidl/compat/libradiocompat/network/RadioNetwork.cpp b/radio/aidl/compat/libradiocompat/network/RadioNetwork.cpp
index 8bfa0bb..156fdd2 100644
--- a/radio/aidl/compat/libradiocompat/network/RadioNetwork.cpp
+++ b/radio/aidl/compat/libradiocompat/network/RadioNetwork.cpp
@@ -255,7 +255,13 @@
 ScopedAStatus RadioNetwork::setSignalStrengthReportingCriteria(
         int32_t serial, const std::vector<aidl::SignalThresholdInfo>& infos) {
     LOG_CALL << serial;
-    // TODO(b/203699028): how about other infos?
+    if (infos.size() == 0) {
+        LOG(ERROR) << "Threshold info array is empty - dropping setSignalStrengthReportingCriteria";
+        return ok();
+    }
+    if (infos.size() > 1) {
+        LOG(WARNING) << "Multi-element reporting criteria are not supported with HIDL HAL";
+    }
     mHal1_5->setSignalStrengthReportingCriteria_1_5(serial, toHidl(infos[0]),
                                                     V1_5::AccessNetwork(infos[0].ran));
     return ok();
@@ -292,18 +298,17 @@
     return ok();
 }
 
-// TODO(b/210498497): is there a cleaner way to send a response back to Android, even though these
-// methods must never be called?
-ScopedAStatus RadioNetwork::setUsageSetting(
-        int32_t ser, ::aidl::android::hardware::radio::network::UsageSetting) {
-    LOG_CALL << ser;
+ScopedAStatus RadioNetwork::setUsageSetting(int32_t serial, aidl::UsageSetting) {
+    LOG_CALL << serial;
     LOG(ERROR) << "setUsageSetting is unsupported by HIDL HALs";
+    respond()->setUsageSettingResponse(notSupported(serial));
     return ok();
 }
 
-ScopedAStatus RadioNetwork::getUsageSetting(int32_t ser) {
-    LOG_CALL << ser;
+ScopedAStatus RadioNetwork::getUsageSetting(int32_t serial) {
+    LOG_CALL << serial;
     LOG(ERROR) << "getUsageSetting is unsupported by HIDL HALs";
+    respond()->getUsageSettingResponse(notSupported(serial), {});  // {} = neither voice nor data
     return ok();
 }